Top Auto Insurance Companies In the USA For 2023

UPDATED: AUGUST 12, 2023 | 3 MIN READ

Auto insurance is necessary for your financial safety net when driving. In the event of an accident, collision, or theft, car insurance can help cover the costs of repairs or replacement — and the top auto insurance companies tend to take care of things like this better than the rest.

While there are many auto insurance companies, some are better than others. Here are the top six auto insurance companies in the USA based on rates, available coverage, and discounts.

Top Auto Insurance Companies In the USA

1. Allstate
2. Progressive
3. GAINSCO
4. Toggle
5. Acceptance
6. AssuranceAmerica

Allstate

Established in 1931, Allstate has over 54,000 local agents ready to help you find insurance that fits your needs. Additionally, the company owns Esurance, which is ideal for anyone who wants to purchase and handle their insurance transactions online.

Allstate premiums

Compared to some of the other large insurance companies in the U.S., such as State Farm, Progressive, and GEICO, Allstate tends to have higher premiums.

For example, the average premium for an adult with a good driving record costs about $1,315 for six months through Progressive, while Allstate policyholders can expect to pay around $2,800. It seems like a steep difference, but Allstate shines regarding coverage options.

Allstate coverage options

Allstate distinguishes itself from its competitors by offering coverages that others don’t through its Your Choice Auto program. One example is its rideshare insurance program, which covers rideshare services like Uber and Lyft.

Other coverages from Allstate include:

• Liability
• Property damage
• Uninsured motorist
• Gap insurance
• Rental reimbursement
• Roadside assistance

Discounts available through Allstate

Allstate has a lot of discounts to offer its customers, which can lower your premiums significantly.

The company rewards policyholders who drive safely through its Drivewise program. This program monitors how you drive and discounts your premiums based on your actions. According to Allstate, the Drivewise program can save policyholders up to 40%.

Other discounts available include:

• Anti-lock brakes discount
• Responsible payer discount
• Homeowner discount
• Bundling your home and auto policies
• Passive restraint discount
• Premier discount
• Premier plus discount
• Senior adult discount
• 55 and retired discount
• Resident student discount
• Good Hands People discount
• Defensive driving course discount
• FullPay discount
• Smart student discount
• eSmart discount
• Early signing discount
• Allstate Easy Pay discount
• Anti-theft discount
• New car discount
• Daytime running lights discount
• Utility car discount
• Economy car discount
• Farm vehicle discount

Progressive

It’s not surprising that Progressive has a J.D. Power score of 819 for customer satisfaction. The company offers competitive rates, especially for drivers who have previous accidents on their record.

However, its homeowners and renters policies are lacking a bit. So if you want to carry both policies with the same company, Progressive may not be the right option.

Progressive premiums

Progressive’s insurance policy premiums average lower than Allstate, Farmers, and State Farm for middle-aged drivers with good driving records. For example, Progressive’s average six-month premium for a 40-year-old male is $1,525, while Farmers’s average is $2,055.

For young drivers, though, Progressive’s insurance premiums aren’t ideal. On average, the company’s six-month premium for an 18-year-old male is $3,790, which is a bit high when compared to State Farm’s average of $3,135.

High-risk drivers might also save money by switching to Progressive. It’s known as one of the best car insurance companies for drivers with DUIs.

Progressive coverage options

Most national insurance companies offer similar car insurance coverages, Progressive included. So you can choose between liability-only or full-coverage insurance and add additional options, such as gap coverage.

While most coverage options are pretty standard, Progressive does also offer two unique coverages — pet injury and custom parts and equipment.

Pet injury coverage pays your pet’s vet bills if he’s injured in a car accident. This coverage comes as part of your collision coverage. This means it’s only available if you have full-coverage insurance and pay the deductible before the company pays the vet bills.

Custom parts and equipment coverage is additional coverage you can add to your policy if you have a customized vehicle. It covers the difference in cost between manufacturer-grade parts and after-market car parts.

Discounts through Progressive

Progressive’s discounts are pretty standard too. They offer their policyholders multiple-policy, multi-car, and homeowner discounts, which is similar to what other auto insurance carriers offer.

Drivers can also save money by participating in the company’s Snapshot program. This program monitors your driving habits to help you earn additional discounts for driving safely.

Another unique discount Progressive offers is the Start Your Quote Online discount. It’s available to any policyholder who starts their quote online and then purchases a policy over the phone.

Progressive’s other discounts include:

• Continuous insurance
• Signing insurance documents online
• Paying policy premiums in full
• Automatic bill pay
• Good student
• Teen driver

GAINSCO

If you’re looking for liability-only insurance, GAINSCO is a great option. However, it only offers the state’s minimum liability coverage or full-coverage insurance. You can’t increase the limits.

It also has a reputation for being a good insurance company for high-risk drivers.

The company writes insurance policies in 19 different states, including:

• Alabama
• Arizona
• Arkansas
• Florida
• Georgia
• Illinois
• Indiana
• Mississippi
• Missouri
• New Mexico
• Ohio
• Oklahoma
• Oregon
• South Carolina
• Tennessee
• Texas
• Utah
• Virginia
• Wisconsin

GAINSCO premiums

With average six-month premiums hovering around $440 for liability coverage, GAINSCO is cheaper than Allstate and Nationwide.

The company also comes in cheaper for drivers with an accident or DUI on their record. Six-month liability insurance costs through GAINSCO averages $565 for drivers with an accident and $540 for drivers with a DUI, while Allstate charges an average of $765 and $1,280, respectively.

When you add comprehensive and collision coverage to a GAINSCO policy, expect to pay about double the average premium for liability coverage.

GAINSCO coverage options

GAINSCO’s coverage options are lacking a bit. Its liability coverage limits only go up to the state minimum, and there’s no way to increase them. So if you have a lot of assets and need more coverage, GAINSCO may not be the right option.

However, you can add comprehensive and collision coverage to your policy to protect your vehicle. The company doesn’t offer a lot of additional coverages, though, as most larger insurance companies do.

Discounts through GAINSCO

Gainsco doesn’t offer quite as many insurance discounts as larger insurers. Still, its car insurance rates for liability-only coverage are favorable compared to larger companies like Liberty Mutual, State Farm, and GEICO.

Most of GAINSCO’s discounts revolve around policy payments and management. You’ll find discounts for:

• Having your payment automatically deducted from your checking account
• Paying your six-month policy premium in full
• Having insurance coverage for the prior six months without a lapse
• Having a previous six-month policy through GAINSCO
• Purchasing your policy at least three days before the coverage begins
• Being a loyal GAINSCO customer
• Owning a home
• Renewing your auto insurance policy
• Having multiple cars insured on your policy

Toggle

Owned by Farmers, Toggle bills itself as a modern car insurance company — and it is. It’s all digital, so policyholders manage everything online. But that’s not the only way Toggle has strived to modernize car insurance. The company also cancels your old insurance policy for you.

And it actively works to protect the environment with carbon offsets from Cool Effect. Its goal is to use the United States Department of Transportation’s (USDOT) national average of miles each year as a goal to help offset every mile its customers drive.

Also, Toggle’s claims process makes the company stand out even more. While some companies offer apps that allow you to file a claim, Toggle goes further. It provides a white-glove claims service over chat, so you have someone to talk to you through uploading photos through its mobile app, filing your claim, and getting your car fixed.

Toggle premiums

While Toggle doesn’t display their premiums prices online, the company does make it simple to get a quote. Keep in mind, Toggle is a fairly new insurance company and only writes auto insurance policies in these states:

• Arizona
• Illinois
• Indiana
• Ohio
• South Carolina

Toggle coverage options

One big difference between Toggle’s coverage and that of other companies is that Toggle combines comprehensive and collision coverage. So you either have both, or you don’t have either.

This simplifies your coverage options. But it also means Toggle isn’t ideal for anyone who wants to add comprehensive coverage to their liability policy to cover losses from perils they can’t control, such as theft, vandalism, and acts of nature, without the added expense of collision coverage.

The company also has a few semi-unique additional coverages you can add to enhance your policy, including:

• Pet Passenger: Provides coverage for your pet’s vet bills if he’s injured in a car accident
• Side Hustle Auto: Extends the coverage options provided by gig companies, like DoorDash and Uber Eats
• Temporary Ride Coverage: Pays you a daily stipend for transportation if your vehicle is in the shop during the claims process
• New Car Replacement: Covers the difference between the amount you owe on your loan and the vehicle’s worth if your car is deemed a total loss

Discounts through Toggle

The discounts Toggle offers are pretty standard. You can expect to get discounts for:

• Being a homeowner
• Having a “good student” on your policy
• Being accident/claims free
• Having a car with an automatic emergency braking system
• Having a renters policy with Toggle 

Acceptance

If you’re looking for non-standard car insurance, Acceptance might be a good choice. The company offers favorable rates to drivers with DUIs on their driving record and middle-aged drivers. It also has some pretty unique policy features available.

There is a downside, though. Acceptance only has a C++ Financial Strength rating from A.M. Best. This is lower than similar auto insurance companies and often indicates frequent delays with the claims process.

Acceptance only offers car insurance policies in these states:

• Alabama
• Arizona
• California
• Florida
• Georgia
• Illinois
• Indiana
• Mississippi
• Missouri
• Ohio
• Pennsylvania
• South Carolina
• Tennessee
• Texas
• Virginia

Acceptance premiums

Acceptance premiums are a bit high for young drivers, with average costs for an 18-year-old male, with a clean record being around $1,095 for six months. This is slightly higher than The General’s average premium of $1,090 but quite a bit higher than Progressive’s average of $880.

However, middle-aged drivers with a DUI or DWI who need an SR-22 certificate might save a bit with a six-month policy from Acceptance. Its average premium sits around $625, which is lower than GEICO’s average of $1,030.

Acceptance coverage options

Acceptance offers all of the standard coverage options — liability, comprehensive, and collision. It also offers additional coverages, such as rental car coverage and roadside assistance.

Additionally, the company offers some unique add-ons:

• TicketProof: This coverage reimburses you for fines and legal fees of up to $650 annually if you’re convicted of minor traffic offenses, such as speeding slightly or running a stop sign.
• Hospital Indemnity: This coverage covers hospital costs of up to $125 daily if you’re admitted as a direct result of a car accident. It also covers excess medical expenses of $1,000, gives you a blanket discount on prescription drugs, and has accidental death and dismemberment coverage up to $10,000.
• Accidental Death: This coverage pays your beneficiaries if you’re killed in a car accident. If you opt for the hospital indemnity coverage, though, there’s no need to add accidental death. Typically, this coverage is offered with life insurance policies, not car insurance.
• RX Discount: You add the RX discount plan onto your policy without opting into the hospital indemnity plan. It gives you a 20% discount on prescription medication and can be used on any prescription.

Discounts through Acceptance

Acceptance has many discounts available, which does help offset the high premiums a bit. However, even with discounts, people who aren’t considered high-risk will typically find better prices with a standard insurance company.

Discounts available include:

• Multipolicy
• Allowing Acceptance to use telematics to track driving habits
• Renewal with Acceptance
• Military
• Paperless
• Safe driving
• Multiple cars
• Automatic monthly payments
• Paying your policy in full
• Signing up for a policy online
• Continuous insurance — at least six months of coverage without lapses
• Owning a home
• Affiliations with some clubs and organizations
• Good student
• Defensive driving course completion
• Low-milage on your car

AssuranceAmerica

AssuranceAmerica primarily caters to drivers who need a non-standard insurance company. The company doesn’t have J.D. Power or A.M. Best customer satisfaction ratings. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) has the company rated as “Poor” due to customer complaints that surpass the national average.

The company isn’t all bad, though. For drivers with a not-so-great record, less-than-stellar credit score, or a lapse in coverage, AssuranceAmerica could be a cost-effective option.

AssuranceAmerica premiums

Like Toggle, AssuranceAmerica doesn’t display its average rates online. But the company does give you the option to get an online quote.

Remember that it’s a small insurance company that works primarily through independent insurance agents and caters to high-risk drivers. So its best rate might be slightly higher than other insurance providers.

If you don’t need non-standard insurance or you need the best insurance for gig workers, choosing a larger company that writes standard insurance policies, like American Family Insurance or USAA (if you’re a military family), might be your best option.

AssuranceAmerica only offers auto insurance coverage in these 10 states:

• Alabama
• Arizona
• Florida
• Georgia
• Indiana
• Missouri
• Nebraska
• South Carolina
• Texas
• Virginia

AssuranceAmerica coverage options

AssuranceAmerica doesn’t have as many add-on coverage options as Acceptance, but it does give you several options for customizing your coverage. The company offers liability-only and full-coverage insurance.

Policyholders also have the option to increase their liability coverage. They can also add uninsured motorists and medical payments coverage to their policy.

Discounts through AssuranceAmerica

Unfortunately, AssuranceAmerica doesn’t offer as many discounts as some other providers. But the company does have a handful of discounts to help lower your policy costs, including:

• Homeowner
• Military
• Continuous coverage for the past six months
• Sam’s Club members
• Costco members
• BJ’s Wholesale Club members

FAQs

Who is the number 1 auto insurer in the U.S.?

Progressive stands out as one of the best car insurance companies in the U.S. The large insurance provider offers a wide range of car insurance coverage options, has a mobile app to streamline the claims process, and offers an accident forgiveness program.

What is the best car insurance right now?

Some of the best car insurance companies include Progressive, State Farm, Allstate, Travelers, and Erie. These companies have many coverage and discount options, as well as favorable rates and ratings with J.D. Power and A.M Best.

What is the cheapest car insurance?

The cheapest car insurance is liability-only coverage. This type of insurance pays for any damage or injuries you cause but doesn’t cover costs to repair or replace your vehicle.

Additionally, you need to add medical payments or personal injury protection (PIP) coverage to your policy to ensure your medical bills are covered in an at-fault accident. Most companies also allow drivers to enhance their liability-only policies by adding uninsured motorists coverage.

Find the best rates from the top auto insurance companies

The bottom line is, if you have a good driving record, a decent credit score, and haven’t had any coverage lapses, companies like Allstate, Progressive, and Toggle are probably better for you.

However, if you’re a high-risk driver, you might find more favorable rates with companies specializing in non-standard coverage, such as Acceptance, AssuranceAmerica, and GAINSCO.

To find the best possible rates from the top auto insurance companies, you should compare prices and coverages from several companies. Fortunately, you can do that online in minutes with our free quoting tool.